Venue: Upper Guildhall, High Street, Andover, Hampshire
Contact: Sally Prior - 01264 368024
Email: sprior@testvalley.gov.uk
Items
No. |
Item |
233. |
Public Participation
Minutes:
In accordance with the
Council’s scheme of Public Participation, the following spoke
on the applications indicated:
Agenda Item No.
|
Page No.
|
Application
|
Speaker
|
7
|
10 -
89
|
18/00936/FULLN
|
Mr Williams
(Hurstbourne Tarrant Parish
Council)
Mr Foxley (Objector)
Mr Buckley
(Supporter)
Mr Martin
(Applicant)
|
8
|
90
– 129
|
Waste
to Energy Harewood
Incinerator
|
Mr Cooper (Barton
Stacey Parish Council)
Mrs Dryden
(Longparish Parish Council) and Mr
Yelf (Keep Test Valley Beautiful)
(Objectors)
|
Councillor North made
representation on application 18/00936/FULLN.
Councillor Drew made
representation on the Waste to Energy Harewood Incinerator item.
|
234. |
Minutes
Minutes:
Resolved:
That
the minutes of the meeting held on 3 October 2019 be confirmed and
signed as a correct record.
|
235. |
18/00936/FULLN PDF 647 KB
(OFFICER RECOMMENDATION: REFUSE)
SITE: Bourne Park Airfield, Bourne Park Estate, Hurstbourne Tarrant, SP11 0DG, HURSTBOURNE TARRANT
CASE OFFICER: Miss Emma Jones
Additional documents:
Minutes:
|
APPLICATION NO.
|
18/00936/FULLN
|
|
APPLICATION TYPE
|
FULL APPLICATION -
NORTH
|
|
REGISTERED
|
06.04.2018
|
|
APPLICANT
|
Mr. J Martin and Mr. R Wood
|
|
SITE
|
Bourne Park Airfield,
Bourne Park Estate, Hurstbourne
Tarrant, SP11 0DG, HURSTBOURNE
TARRANT
|
|
PROPOSAL
|
Demolition of buildings associated
with Bourne Park Airfield, and removal of existing airstrip and
outdoor storage areas;
Erection of detached dwelling
and outbuildings; with associated parking, turning, landscaping,
access, private amenity space and ecological
enhancements
|
|
AMENDMENTS
|
Additional information
received:
- 22.08.2019
- 23.08.2019
- 21.10.2019
- 29.10.2019
|
|
CASE
OFFICER
|
Miss Emma Jones
|
|
|
|
Members of the NAPC considered that the current activity taking
place on the site is causing significant harm to the amenities of
residents and as such the proposed development would comply with
the requirements of policy LE10 of the Test Valley Borough Council
Revised Local Plan 2016. As such it was
resolved to delegate to the Head of Planning and Building to grant
PERMISSION subject to the submission of (i) An acceptable nitrate mitigation scheme; (ii)
The undertaking of an Appropriate Assessment; (iii) The
satisfactory conclusion of consultation with Natural England; (iv)
The completion of a legal agreement to secure the nitrate
mitigation measures; and subject to
conditions and notes as considered appropriate by the Head of
Planning and Building following consultation with the
applicant.
|
|
236. |
Waste to Energy Harewood Incinerator PDF 418 KB
(OFFICER RECOMMENDATION:
OBJECTION)
SITE: Land to the west of the
Raymond Brown Waste Solutions, A303
Enviropark, Drayton Road, Barton
Stacey, Andover, SO21 3QS
CASE OFFICER: Mrs Samantha
Owen
Additional documents:
Minutes:
|
SITE
|
Land to the west of the
Raymond Brown Waste Solutions, A303 Enviropark, Drayton Road, Barton Stacey, Andover,
SO21 3QS BARTON
STACEY
|
|
PROPOSAL
|
A Waste to Energy
Facility comprising a twin line facility (i.e. two boiler and flue
gas treatment lines) capable of processing a total of up to
500,000
tonnes of waste per annum (tpa),
with a gross electrical generating capacity of up to 65 MW. The
facility would generate hot gases that in turn are used to produce
steam for use in a steam turbine to generate
electricity.
|
|
CASE
OFFICER
|
Mrs
Samantha Owen
|
|
|
|
|
That the Northern Area
Planning Committee (NAPC) OBJECTS to this submission on the basis
of inadequate information which has been submitted for Public
Consultation including that contained within the PEIR. It
is strongly recommended that further consultation with the public
should occur. The NAPC endorses this report together with the full responses of
consultees as Test Valley Borough Council’s response to the
Public Consultation process.
The
following consultee comments should be noted in
particular:
- Air Quality - the
PEIR is premature in presenting its work so far as it transpires
that insufficient work has been undertaken to make any assessment
in relation to the impact of the proposed
development.
- It is considered
that with regard to Noise and Vibration the information supplied
within the PEIR is deficient.
- Ground
Contamination - the PEIR is premature in presenting its work so far
as it transpires that insufficient work has been undertaken to make
any assessment in relation to the impact of the proposed
development.
- In relation to
Socio-Economic issues the PEIR does not address adequately
the impacts of the
incinerator on tourism which is influenced by a number of factors
and whilst this is acknowledged it is considered that more work is
needed on the impact of tourism in the local
area.
- With regard to
Landscape and Visual Impact Assessment the PEIR
is currently inadequate and
significantly more work is required in order to fully assess the
impact of the proposal on the surrounding
landscape.
|
|
|
- Alternatives to
the proposed location should have been shared at this stage through
the PEIR and in accordance with the Infrastructure Planning (Environmental Impact Assessment)
Regulations 2017.
- The proposed
development would reduce energy production at the solar farm by
0.55% and it is not clear if the proposed mitigation would address
this shortfall.
- It is
advised within the PEIR that connection to the grid will be applied
for separately by the Distribution Network Operator (DNO).
Due to its location connection to the grid could have significant
environmental impacts and this should be considered in conjunction
with the scheme. It would appear to not
accord with Government guidance on generating stations and grid
connection contained within the relevant National Policy
Statement
·
Water Demand - the PEIR’s contention that the impact on water resources and flood risk
during construction, operation and decommissioning would not be
significant does not appear to be justified by supporting
evidence. It would appear that
the ...
view the full minutes text for item 236.
|
|